My Name is Mary Sutter by Robin Oliviera
Listen to an excerpt on Penguin Audio Book Break (yes, I’m the producer and it’s an great program)
I think this was a pretty entertaining Civil War era story. Gone with the Wind it ain’t but that’s not a bad thing. Mary Sutter is a determined woman who wants to be a doctor and everyone thinks she’s nuts. Of course, us modern folks know she’s not and can share her indignation over her rejection from Medical School.
Luckily for Mary the war starts in the first chapter and she can go down to Washington and force her way into surgeoning. Too bad it doesn’t turn out to be the fulfilling career choice Mary hoped it would be. Contrary to what I learned on Grey’s Anatomy studying to be a surgeon doesn’t involve hot makeout sessions or even clean, sterilized equipment. Being a surgeon in the Civil War meant cutting off legs with no latex gloves, not much water and certainly nothing as paltry as washing hands in between operations. To be fair, they certainly wanted to get as many limbs off as possible with the countless men laying on the dirt at times injured and bleeding, waiting to be treated.
If they couldn’t perform surgery for what ailed their wounded soldiers, the best they could do was often just giving the patients whiskey. Contrary to what you might be thinking, they didn’t give them whiskey while amputating unless they had no choice. The preferred method was chloroform, so if you didn’t watch out you could kill your patient with that as well.
The crazy thing about listening to audio books is when you read a book, you can just skim over unsavory parts about cutting through muscles and all the blood. But when someone is reading the book to you (an excellent Kimberly Farr who apparently also did part of The 19th Wife, which I enjoyed on audio), if you’re like me and easily grossed out, the audio book drives home the stark misery of the Civil War. There is no glory and honor. Just men trying to survive. Everyone loses someone dear to them in this book, sometimes from stupid things like unknown infections or rifles discharging while being cleaned. But through all the misery, there is the compelling heroine.
Mary is not flawless, she has her own foibles, which makes the story work. Mary is a modern woman going for her goal but held back by her time period. My main disappointment with this book is how the love story resolves itself but then I often think love stories are hatchet jobs and not really necessary to the plot line. So if you’re a romantic at heart, you might enjoy it.